Gamemastering >Other Rule Systems >Variant Rules (3rd Party) >Adamant Entertainment >

Drawbacks

One of the more interesting concepts in The Pathfinder Roleplaying Game is the concept of Feats. While any two fighters or wizards will look more or less the same in class abilities and skills, it is their Feats that differentiate them. One fighter might use his Feat slots to become more skilled in mounted combat, while another might strive to be an excellent archer. Even at low levels, these two fighters will look and act very differently in combat.

In literature and popular culture, characters are often just as, if not more, defined by their faults than their abilities. Othello was gullible, and this enabled Iago to manipulate him. Han Solo was notable for his mercenary attitude. Captain Hook is remembered for…well, his hook. These faults, or drawbacks, lend color to the characters that have them. This chapter is designed to add these drawbacks to player characters.

How it Works

Some Gamemasters may balk at the idea of drawbacks because of their perception as negative Feats. Such systems tend to grant the player an extra Feat in return for taking a drawback, making starting player characters a bit more powerful. This can seriously unbalance a campaign. Character Drawbacks resolves this problem by granting skill points for each drawback instead of an extra Feat. It is a common complaint among players that they never have enough skill points to accurately reflect what their characters know. Since the skill level caps are still in place (you may have no more ranks in a skill than your total number of hit dice), player characters will not be seriously overpowered by taking Drawbacks. Indeed, Drawbacks are intended to add a little spice to a character concept and offer the player appropriate and significant compensation for taking them, not to create headaches for the Game Master.

Each drawback below is worth 4 skill ranks. Some drawbacks have prerequisites, including other drawbacks. Players may spend these points on their character sheet however they wish, but they must still abide by the usual skill rank limitations. Unlike feats, players may only select drawbacks at first level, although the Game Master may grant a new drawback to an existing character if he wishes. Any drawbacks gained during play will grant the appropriate amount of skill points to the character upon reaching next level (GMs may waive this and grant the skill points immediately if desired or if the PC has a particularly long wait until he reaches next level). There is no set amount of drawbacks that a PC can take, although GMs should probably limit the number of drawbacks to two or three. GMs should feel free to create new drawbacks. A good drawback should give penalties equivalent to the bonuses offered to feats in order to maintain game balance. Good drawbacks also have concrete penalties rather than relying on the player to “roleplay” his drawback. Roleplaying a drawback is always a good thing, but penalties should be easily measured and applied.

Character Drawbacks

Drawback Prerequisite Detriment Source
Abrasive Attitude When using Diplomacy to change attitudes, you must add an extra 5 to the DC. AE:ToS
Albinism Make a Fortitude save each hour you are in the sunlight or take 1d4 sunburn damage AE:ToS
All Thumbs You take a –2 penalty on all Disable Device and Sleight of Hand checks. AE:ToS
Animal Antipathy You take a –2 penalty on all Handle Animal and Ride checks. AE:ToS
Awkward Gestures Bard, Sorcerer, or Wizard You have a natural 5% arcane spell failure chance. AE:ToS
Bad Luck Once per session, the GM can negate any success AE:ToS
Bad Shot You take a –2 penalty on all ranged attacks. AE:ToS
Bleeder You cannot stabilize while dying. AE:ToS
Clumsy You take a –2 penalty on all Acrobatics checks. AE:ToS
Cold Aversion You suffer a -2 circumstance penalty to all saving throws and skill checks in cold environments. AE:ToS
Cowardice You will always maintain a defensive position until attacked.  If you defeat your foe, you will attempt to hide or flee rather than engage another foe. AE:ToS
Deaf Hard of Hearing You cannot learn the Linguistics skill. In addition, you have a 20% chance of spell failure when casting a spell with a verbal component. AE:ToS
Deity’s Wrath You add 1 to the DC of any save you must make against any spells invoked in the name of a particular deity. Healing spells and other aid from that deity will not work on you. AE:ToS
Easily Read Your opponents get a +4 to their Sense Motive checks when using it against you. AE:ToS
Fanatic You take a –2 penalty to any Knowledge checks when researching things that go against your beliefs. AE:ToS
Frail You have 3 less hit points than normal. AE:ToS
Gullible You take a –2 penalty on Diplomacy and Sense Motive checks. AE:ToS
Hard of Hearing You take a –2 penalty on sound-based Perception checks and Stealth checks. AE:ToS
Heat Aversion
You suffer a -2 circumstance penalty to all saving throws and skill checks in hot environments. AE:ToS
Honest You take a –2 penalty on Bluff and Intimidate checks. AE:ToS
Impatient Your character may never ‘take 10’ or ‘take 20’ on any skill check, no matter how much time he has. AE:ToS
Ineffective Racial Trait You do not receive the benefit of one of the positive racial traits for your character. AE:ToS
Intolerance You take a –4 penalty when making skill checks against a particular group. AE:ToS
Lame You only move two-thirds of what is normal for your race. AE:ToS
Magical Ineptitude You take a –2 penalty on all Spellcraft checks and Use Magic Device checks. AE:ToS
Marked You take a –2 penalty to all Bluff and Diplomacy checks when dealing with people that would recognize the mark. AE:ToS
Minority Culture You take a –2 penalty to all Diplomacy checks against members of the primary culture. AE:ToS
Missing Hand You may not use a two-handed weapon. You also take a –2 penalty on all Climb, Disable Device and Sleight of Hand checks. AE:ToS
Mute You take a –4 penalty on any skill checks that would normally require you to speak. AE:ToS
Oblivious You take a –2 penalty on all Perception checks. AE:ToS
One Eye You take an extra –1 penalty per range increment when using a ranged weapon. AE:ToS
Quick Spell Discharge Spellcasting class Any touch spell cast must immediately manifest or you lose it. AE:ToS
Restless Spellcasting class You automatically add 2 hours to your spell preparation time. AE:ToS
School Deficiency Spellcasting class You never learn or cast spells from a spell school. AE:ToS
Short You move slower and may have reduced reach. AE:ToS
Slow Healer With a full night’s rest, you only recover 1 hit point for every two character levels. Magical healing effects are also halved. AE:ToS
Slow Preparation Spellcasting class You take more time than usual to prepare your spells. AE:ToS
Slow Reflexes You take a –2 penalty on all Reflex saving throws. AE:ToS
Spineless You take a –2 penalty on all Will saving throws. AE:ToS
Taboo Proficiency You do not receive one of the starting weapon or armor proficiencies normally available for your class. AE:ToS
Uncomely You take a –2 circumstance penalty on any Bluff or Diplomacy checks when dealing with someone of the other gender. AE:ToS
Weak Fortitude You take a –2 penalty on all Fortitude saving throws. AE:ToS

Character Drawback Details

Abrasive Attitude

You have a way of rubbing people the wrong way when you speak. This could be due to your natural belligerence, boastfulness, uncouthness, or other personality flaw.

Detriment: When using Diplomacy to change attitudes, you must add an extra 5 to the DC.

Albinism

You lack pigmentation in your skin, giving you a distinctively pale appearance. Your skin is very sensitive to sunlight.

Detriment: You must make a Fortitude saving throw for every hour that your skin is exposed to direct sunlight. The DC is 15 +1 for every hour that you’ve been exposed. A failure causes 1d4 hit points of sunburn damage.

All Thumbs

You aren’t very coordinated when it comes to fine manipulation.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on all Disable Device and Sleight of Hand checks.

Animal Antipathy

Perhaps you have a bad smell. Maybe they can detect the way you truly feel about them. Maybe they just don’t like you. For whatever reason, you have trouble dealing with animals.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on all Handle Animal and Ride checks.

Awkward Gestures

Maybe you have stiff joints. Maybe your arms are just a little too long. Whatever the reason, you have trouble making the elegant gestures necessary to cast arcane spells.

Prerequisite: You must be a bard, sorcerer or wizard to select this drawback.

Detriment: You have a natural 5% arcane spell failure chance. This stacks with armor penalties.

Bad Luck

Whenever you need luck most, you can count on it not being there.

Detriment: Once per session, the GM can negate any success, even if it was a critical hit. This will usually be when you desperately need to succeed.

Bad Shot

You are unpracticed or inept at making ranged attacks.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on all ranged attacks.

Bleeder

Your body has trouble stabilizing. When dying, you continue to bleed until you are dead.

Detriment: You cannot stabilize while dying. Unless you are treated or healed, you will continue to lose one hit point every round until you are dead.

Clumsy

You are exceptionally uncoordinated and tend to slip at the most inopportune times.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on all Acrobatics checks.

Cold Aversion

Your body has a hard time adjusting to the rigors of very cold climates.

Detriment: You suffer a -2 circumstance penalty to all saving throws and skill checks in temperatures at or below 40 degrees Fahrenheit. You also suffer an inherent -1 penalty to saving throws made against cold-based spells, damage, and area effects. Cold-weather clothing alone will not remove this penalty.

Cowardice

You are a coward. You usually choose the safest position in a marching order and rely on others to protect you.

Detriment: Cowards never initiate combat, even when it is to their advantage. You will always maintain a defensive position until attacked. If you defeat your foe, you will attempt to hide or flee rather than engage another foe.

Deaf

You can’t hear at all.

Prerequisite: You must have the Hard of Hearing drawback to select this drawback.

Detriment: You cannot learn the Linguistics skill. In addition, you have a 20% chance of spell failure when casting a spell with a verbal component.

Deity’s Wrath

You have angered a particular god or goddess.

Detriment: You add 1 to the DC of any save you must make against any spells invoked in the name of a particular deity. Healing spells and other aid from that deity will not work on you. The GM should restrict this drawback to common deities in his campaign.

Special: At the GM’s option, you may drop this drawback by using a free feat slot. You must also perform some penance in the name of the affected deity.

Easily Read

You wear your heart on your sleeve. Others can almost read your thoughts.

Detriment: Your opponents get a +4 to their Sense Motive checks when using it against you.

Fanatic

You are so committed to one philosophy or religion that it blinds you to others.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty to any Knowledge checks when researching histories, religions, or even arcane lore at odds with your own faith. In addition, you will refuse personal aid from any cleric or druid that is contrary to your faith.

Special: If you are a cleric or a paladin, you will refuse aid to anyone that doesn’t adhere to your faith.

Frail

You are weaker than normal, either due to illness or genetics.

Detriment: You have 3 less hit points than normal.

Special: This drawback may be taken multiple times. A character may only take this feat if doing so will still leave him with at least one hit point. For example, a character with 8 hit points may take this drawback twice, but a character with 6 hit points may only take it once.

Gullible

You are easily persuaded and manipulated by others.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on Diplomacy and Sense Motive checks.

Hard of Hearing

You have lost part of your hearing, making it difficult for you to be aware of all sounds surrounding you. You also have a problem being stealthy.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on sound-based Perception checks and Stealth checks.

Heat Aversion

Your body has a hard time adjusting to the rigors of very hot climates.

Detriment: You suffer a -2 circumstance penalty to all saving throws and skill checks in tropical or desert conditions (or in artificial conditions of extreme heat, such as steam baths). At the GM’s discretion, you may suffer these penalties in any area where the temperature is above 80 degrees Fahrenheit. He also suffers an inherent -1 penalty to saving throws made against heat-based spells, damage, and area effects.

Honest

You have trouble telling lies or concealing the truth.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on Bluff and Intimidate checks.

Impatient

Your character is notoriously incapable of focusing his attention long and hard enough to accomplish tasks requiring great dedication.

Detriment: Your character may never ‘take 10’ or ‘take 20’ on any skill check, no matter how much time he has.

Ineffective Racial Trait

You lack one of your positive racial traits, either due to mixed lineage in your character’s past or a simple genetic anomaly. A gnome might not have keen senses, while an elf may be lacking low-light vision (“unfortunately, you have your human grandfather’s eyes”).

Detriment: You do not receive the benefit of one of the positive racial traits for your character (including the extra feat for human characters).

Intolerance

You have a particular hatred for a certain class, race, or culture.

Detriment: You take a –4 penalty when making skill checks against a particular group. The GM should limit this feat to frequently encountered groups within his campaign (for example, if you take Intolerance against Psions, but your campaign rarely includes them, the GM can prohibit this. You may still hate Psions, but it’s not worth four skill ranks).

Special: You may take this drawback multiple times. You choose a new group each time.

Lame

You walk with a discernible limp.

Detriment: You only move two-thirds of what is normal for your race. A lightly armored human, for example, would move 20ft rather than 30ft.

Magical Ineptitude

You find magic difficult to master.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on all Spellcraft checks and Use Magic Device checks.

Special: You may never take the Magical Aptitude feat.

Marked

You have been convicted of a crime in the past (whether you were guilty or not) and bear a lasting mark from the punishment. This mark could be a distinctive scar, tattoo, or missing body part. People treat you as a criminal. This drawback may be coupled with another (missing hand, for example), in which case the other drawback is the mark.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty to all Bluff and Diplomacy checks when dealing with people that would recognize the mark (which is most of the time). You also add an extra 5 to your DC when trying to change an NPC’s attitude.

Special: You get a +2 bonus to Intimidate if the victim recognizes your mark.

Minority Culture

You belong to a smaller culture within a primary culture that has certain rules and taboos that easily distinguish it from the primary culture. You unintentionally but easily offend members of the primary culture.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty to all Diplomacy checks against members of the primary culture. In addition, you add 5 to your DC when attempting to influence the attitudes of members of the primary culture.

Special: GMs should be careful when allowing this drawback. A “primary culture” is the dominant group within a particular campaign. If the campaign takes the characters throughout the world, then this drawback should only be available if the particular minority group is a minority culture throughout that world. “Culture” should be loosely defined. If most of the campaign takes place within the walls of a noble’s castle, then a PC peasant farmer could be considered a “minority culture.” Similarly, a “minority culture” is not necessarily the disadvantaged one. If the PCs are mostly pirates, then a PC noble forced into joining them could be considered from a “minority culture.”

Missing Hand

You have lost a hand in combat.

Detriment: You may not use a two-handed weapon. You may still use a shield. You also take a –2 penalty on all Climb, Disable Device and Sleight of Hand checks.

Mute

You cannot speak.

Detriment: You take a –4 penalty on any skill checks that would normally require you to speak. While you may continue to learn new languages, you may only understand them, not speak them.

Oblivious

Your mind wanders so much that you fail to take note of what’s going on around you.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on all Perception checks.

One Eye

You have lost the use of an eye. This hinders your depth perception as well as hinders your ability to engage foes on your blind side.

Detriment: You take an extra –1 penalty per range increment when using a ranged weapon.

Quick Spell Discharge

You are unable to hold the charge of touch spells.

Prerequisite: This drawback is only available to spellcasting classes.

Detriment: Any touch spell cast must immediately manifest or you lose it.

Restless

You have trouble remaining calm while preparing spells. You habitually interrupt your own rest.

Prerequisite: This drawback is only available to spellcasting classes.

Detriment: You automatically add 2 hours to your spell preparation time.

School Deficiency

Your natural magical abilities have one glaring limitation.

Prerequisite: This drawback is only available to spellcasting classes.

Deficiency: You must select one of the eight schools of magic (the universal school may not be selected). You never learn or cast spells from that school.

Special: If you are a specialist, you must select a school of magic that is not already prohibited to you.  You may take this drawback multiple times, with the GM’s permission. Each time it is taken it applies to a different school of magic.

Short

You are unusually small for your race.

Detriment: Humans, elves, and half-elves are treated as halflings for purposes of tactical speed and reach. Short half-orcs are treated as dwarves. Short dwarves have a tactical speed of 15 ft. and a natural reach of 0. Short gnomes and halflings have a tactical speed of 15 ft. (or 10 ft. when wearing medium or heavy armor) and a natural reach of 0.

Slow Healer

It takes you longer than normal to heal.

Detriment: With a full night’s rest, you only recover 1 hit point for every two character levels. Magical healing effects are also halved.

Slow Preparation

You are unusually slow when dealing with certain formal rituals of magic, including preparing your daily spells from your spellbooks.

Prerequisite: This drawback is only available to spellcasting classes.

Detriment: You must spend 2 hours (rather than 1) studying your spellbooks in order to prepare spells for any given day. You must spend at least 30 minutes when studying a smaller portion of your daily spell allotment.

Slow Reflexes

You have slower than normal reflexes.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on all Reflex saving throws.

Special: You may not take the Lightning Reflexes feat.

Spineless

You have a weaker will than normal.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on all Will saving throws.

Special: You may not take the Iron Will feat.

Taboo Proficiency

Due to cultural, personal, or religious restrictions, you have not been trained to use some weapons or armor normally available to your class.

Detriment: You do not receive one of the starting weapon or armor proficiencies normally available for your class.

Special: You may negate this drawback at any time (including character creation) by selecting the taboo proficiency as one of your available feats.

Uncomely

You are particularly unattractive to most people. Note that you may not be physically unattractive, but you may belong to a group that is disliked by most people in the setting.

Detriment: You take a –2 circumstance penalty on any Bluff or Diplomacy checks when dealing with someone of the other gender.

Weak Fortitude

You are weaker than normal.

Detriment: You take a –2 penalty on all Fortitude saving throws.

Special: You may not take the Great Fortitude feat.

Section 15: Copyright Notice – Tome of Secrets
Tome of Secrets, Copyright 2009, Adamant Entertainment, Inc. Authors: Walt Ciechanowski and Gareth-Michael Skarka.

User Comments